Knuckle
Today’s films have a habit of taking a successful concept and repeating it until it does not work. Following this model, let’s make a film. Take the feuding families of Romeo and Juliet and match them with the characters in The Fighter. Here we have two traditional rivals solving family issues with good old fashioned bare-knuckle fist fighting. Now follow these families for twelve years and turn into a documentary. Perhaps the idea of making a documentary that relies on such bombastic characters would be impossible to produce. This is why audiences were amazed when such a fictional sounding experience was shown to be a reality in Ian Palmer’s Knuckle.
Knuckle follows the lives of the feuding Quinn McDonaghs and Joyces as they attempt to solve an on-going family issue by bare-knuckle fighting each other. The concept started when Ian Palmer filmed the wedding of Michael Quinn McDonaghs in 1997 and he learned of this physical confrontation between the two families, who happen to be cousins. The families themselves had already been documenting and promoting these fights years before Palmer appeared. The two families video tape the fights to show their family members who can’t attend and even create homemade tapes antagonizing the other clan into a fight. The issue that started this long-lasting violence was from a family wedding fight that lead to one of the Joyces being killed and a Quinn McDonagh in jail for manslaughter.
Palmer does not address the catalyst for the feud until much later in the film. By having this information start the film the audience would immediately form an antagonistic opinion over the McDonaghs. Palmer actually focuses the storyline around the McDonaghs to avoid this. The film is not about who is right or wrong. The purpose of Knuckle is to capture this foreign way of solving family disputes. The fights themselves are largely graphic which I found intriguing because they were real. With modern society being desensitized by gratuitous violence in film and television it felt somewhat humbling to encounter true violence. The fights had no flow or structure. Some were fairly clean while others were chaotic. Yet, each fight was undoubtedly raw. This sentiment is aided by the fact that Palmer used a run of the mill camcorder to capture these fights.
As the film progresses it becomes more and more clear that the families don’t continue to fight for their original purpose. After a while it becomes more of a sport than it does a way of an means to an end. Referees from neutral clans are brought in to referee the fights and set rules are formed to insure a clean fight. The clans celebrate each victory and become fueled by each defeat. They no longer look at their fighters and family members but as sports stars. Personalized t-shirts are worn and legends are told. Which results in families fighting just to state they have the best fighter. The most odd aspect of these fights are the monetary prizes. For an event that was created to solve an issue it is strange that a cash reward arose. The head of the McDonagh clan stated that the reason why money came to play was because he retired from fighting and the only way the Joyces could get him to fight was to pay him. It is baffling that after so many years of trying to get from point A to point B that these families have yet to realize that they have been off the trail for nearly a decade.
The most interesting aspect of the film is that it spans for over a decade. Progress is expected to be made as the initial instigators die off and a new generation blossoms. However, as generations develop they cycle the habits of their fathers. Near the end of the film we see Michael Quinn McDonagh go from being a scrawny, optimistic newlywed into a steroid fueled monster that now acts as the brash patriarch of the Quinn McDonaghs. Specific players are shown to be true instigators, such as Big Joe Joyce, the Joyce’s patriarch who schedules all of his clan’s fights. Palmer, who also narrates the film, calls special attention to Big Joe Joyce after Big Joe, who is in the late sixties, fights a grandfather from another clan. Noting this fight as just a way for an old man to search for past power, Palmer breaks his neutral demeanor to state how sickened he is by this action.
By capturing the concept of war and its creation on such a small scale, Palmer gives the audience the chance to experience a feud in its true and raw form. Even global disputes have some sort of catalyst and this documentary shows how one spark can cause a fire in an area that it didn’t even touch. The story of the McDonaghs and the Joyces is a unique reflection of how humans will subconsciously take what they desire from a situation. While the characters are not very redeemable, Knuckle provides an important study that captivated audiences. Many left the film intrigued yet apathetic to the future of these families. Hopefully with the expansion of this film less people will view it for the predicament of two clans and start analyzing the universal issue at hand. Knuckle shows us that no matter who started the fire, it is always in the best interest to put it out.
Title: Knuckle
Run Time: 94 minutes
Director: Ian Palmer
Production: Irish Film Board
Sales: Content Media Corporation